Carefully Curated Vinyl for Every Collector
At Black Dog Vinyl Cafe, we believe vinyl is more than just music—it's a gateway to discovery. Every record in our collection has been hand-selected by owners Mike and Cathy Marchetti with a passion for quality, genre diversity, and the stories behind each album.
Whether you're hunting for rare pressings, exploring new genres, or building your collection, you'll find something special. We stock both new and used vinyl, carefully evaluated for condition and authenticity. Our selection celebrates everything from classic rock and jazz to electronic, indie, and beyond.
Got records to sell or trade? We buy vinyl collections and offer fair valuations based on condition, rarity, and genre fit. Drop by in person to browse, ask our staff for recommendations, or inquire about specific genres and artists.
Call (815) 733-6032 for hours and record inquiries
What Makes Our Selection Special
Genre Diversity
From classic vinyl to contemporary pressings, we celebrate all genres. Discover something new every visit.
Quality Over Quantity
Every record is chosen for condition, authenticity, and appeal. We stand behind every sale.
Buy & Trade Service
Sell or trade your collection. Fair valuations within 24 hours. We're always looking for quality vinyl.
Ready to Dig Through Records?
Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, Black Dog has something for you. Stop by during our open hours and browse our curated selection while enjoying a cup of coffee or craft drink.
Sell or Trade Your Vinyl With Us
We're always looking to expand our collection. If you have records you'd like to sell or trade, we make the process simple and fair.
Bring Your Records
Visit Black Dog Vinyl Cafe and bring in the records you'd like to sell or trade. Our team is ready to take a look at what you have.
We Review Your Collection
We'll carefully evaluate your records based on condition, rarity, and genre fit. We typically need 24+ hours to review and assess your collection.
We Make an Offer
Based on our evaluation, we'll make you a fair offer. We consider condition, rarity, genre preferences, and current demand when determining value.
Get Paid or Trade
Accept our offer and receive payment in cash or trade credit toward records in our store. The choice is yours.
What We're Looking For
Condition Matters
We prefer vinyl in good to excellent condition. Sleeves should be intact, and records should play without significant skips or pops.
Genre Focus
We curate our collection carefully. We're particularly interested in rock, indie, jazz, soul, funk, and electronic vinyl that fits our store's vibe.
Rarity & Appeal
We look for records that our customers will want to discover and enjoy. First pressings, limited editions, and hard-to-find albums are especially valuable to us.
Our Standards
We maintain high standards for the vinyl we buy and trade. This ensures that every record in our collection meets the expectations of our customers and supports the integrity of our curated selection. We're transparent about what we're looking for and fair in our evaluations.
We don't buy every record that comes through the door—only those that fit our collection and meet our quality standards. This approach protects both our customers and the value of your collection.
Ready to Sell or Trade?
Give us a call to discuss your collection or to schedule a drop-off. Our team is ready to help.
Call to Discuss Your CollectionPhone: +1-815-733-6032
Pro Tip: We're open Wed 12–7 PM, Thu–Sat 12–10 PM, and Sun 12–4 PM. Call ahead to let us know you're bringing a collection so we can give it the attention it deserves.
What Makes Our Selection Special
We don't just sell records—we curate them with care, passion, and a deep love for music.
Personal Curation by Mike & Cathy
Every record on our shelves has been personally selected by Mike and Cathy Marchetti. We don't stock based on trends or algorithms—we choose vinyl we genuinely believe in and that we know will resonate with music lovers in our community.
Quality Over Quantity
We believe in thoughtful curation over massive inventory. Every record—new or used—meets our standards for sound quality and condition. You won't find clutter here, just vinyl worth your time and collection.
Support for Local Collectors & Musicians
We're part of the Plainfield and Will County music community. We buy records from local collectors, support local artists performing live, and create a space where musicians and vinyl enthusiasts belong.
Discovering Rare & Interesting Records
We're always hunting for the gems—rare pressings, hidden classics, and albums that tell a story. The thrill of discovery is what drives us, and we love helping customers find their next favorite record.
Ask our staff for recommendations. We genuinely love talking about music and helping you find exactly what you're looking for—whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting your vinyl journey.
Call Us to Chat About VinylReady to Dig Through Records?
Black Dog Vinyl Cafe is waiting for you. Browse our curated vinyl, enjoy craft coffee and drinks, and discover why we're Plainfield's favorite music hangout.
Hours
- Monday – TuesdayClosed
- Wednesday12:00 PM – 7:00 PM
- Thursday – Saturday12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday12:00 PM – 4:00 PM
Whether you're hunting for that rare album, looking for a cozy spot to work with great coffee, or planning your next event, Black Dog is the place. Come see us today.